The Short Answer
- Thick cards use point measurements — 55pt, 75pt, 100pt, 130pt, 180pt, 360pt. Measure with calipers before buying supplies.
- Oversized holders required — Standard Card Savers and top loaders will not fit. Use thick-card-specific supplies.
- PSA charges $10-25 extra for thick cards depending on thickness tier.
- Patch condition matters — Faded, stained, or frayed patches lower grade even if card stock is perfect.
- Only grade thick cards worth $200+ — The extra fees and shipping costs make low-value thick cards unprofitable to grade.
How Do You Grade Thick Jersey Patch Cards?
Thick cards — jersey patches, booklet cards, jumbo relics, and multi-layer cards — present unique grading challenges. They do not fit standard holders, cost more to grade, and have additional condition factors (patch quality). This guide covers everything from measuring thickness to shipping these specialty cards to PSA, BGS, and SGC.
Understanding Card Thickness (Points)
Card thickness is measured in "points" (1 point = 0.001 inch). Standard cards are 35pt. Thick cards range from 55pt to 360pt:
| Thickness | Card Types | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| 35pt | Standard cards | Base cards, standard inserts |
| 55pt | Thin relics | Single-color jersey patches |
| 75pt | Standard relics | Most jersey patch cards |
| 100pt | Thick patches | Multi-color patches, prime relics |
| 130pt | Jumbo patches | Jumbo relics, logo patches |
| 180pt | Booklet cards | Dual-panel, triple-panel booklets |
| 360pt | Ultra-thick booklets | Quad-panel booklets, bat barrels |
How to Measure: Use digital calipers to measure the card's thickness at the edge (not the patch). Measure in inches and multiply by 1,000 (0.075 inches = 75pt). When in doubt, buy the next size up — a 75pt card will fit in a 100pt holder, but not vice versa.
Supplies for Thick Cards
Thick cards require specialized supplies. Standard penny sleeves and Card Savers will not fit:
| Supply | For Thickness | Est. Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Thick penny sleeves | 55pt-360pt | $0.05-0.15 each |
| Thick Card Saver / semi-rigid | 55pt-130pt | $0.50-1.00 each |
| Thick top loaders | 55pt-360pt | $0.30-0.75 each |
| Magnetic one-touch (thick) | 55pt-360pt | $2-5 each |
| Team bags (oversized) | All thick cards | $0.10-0.20 each |
| Graded card sleeves (PSA slabs) | PSA thick slabs | $0.25 each |
Where to Buy: BCW Supplies and Ultra Pro carry thick card supplies. Amazon also stocks them, but verify the exact point size before ordering.
Grading Costs for Thick Cards (2026)
All grading companies charge extra for thick cards due to specialized slabs and handling:
| Company | Base Fee | Thick Card Surcharge | Total Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| PSA | $79.99 | $10-25 | $89.99-104.99 |
| BGS | $20-35 | $10-20 | $30-55 |
| SGC | $25+ | $8-15 | $33-40 |
| CGC | $15+ | $8-15 | $23-30 |
Note: These are base surcharges. Booklet cards (180pt+) often require custom pricing — contact the grading company directly for booklet submission guidelines. See our complete PSA cost guide for full pricing details.
Patch Condition Factors
Graders evaluate the patch/relic in addition to the card stock:
Patch Elements Graded
- Patch clarity — Is the fabric clearly visible through the window? Cloudy or scratched windows lower grades.
- Patch color — Faded or discolored patches reduce appeal and may lower grades.
- Patch integrity — Fraying, loose threads, or holes in the fabric are defects.
- Patch placement — Centered in the window is preferred; off-center patches may affect centering sub-grade.
- Patch authenticity — Game-worn vs. event-worn vs. player-worn affects value but not grade.
Premium Patch Types
| Patch Type | Value Impact | Rarity |
|---|---|---|
| Logo patch | Highest — team logo visible | Very rare |
| 3+ color patch | High — multiple fabric colors | Rare |
| NFL shield / NBA logoman | Extreme premium — league logo patch | Ultra rare (1/1 in most sets) |
| Nameplate | High — jersey name visible | Rare |
| Single color | Standard — solid color fabric | Common |
Pro Tip: Patch cards with league logos (NFL shield, NBA logoman) are often 1/1 (one-of-one) and can be worth thousands even in lower grades. Always check if your patch card has a premium patch before deciding whether to grade. Use our AI tool to identify patch types and estimate values.
Shipping Thick Cards
Thick cards require more robust shipping protection due to weight and rigidity:
- Use thick Card Savers or top loaders — Standard holders crack under pressure from thick cards
- Extra bubble wrap — Thick cards are heavier and need more cushioning
- Rigid boxes only — No padded envelopes; thick cards will bend
- Team bags — Seal holders in team bags to prevent shifting
- Insurance — Thick cards are often high-value; insure accordingly ($1 per $100)
Booklet Card Shipping: Booklet cards (180pt+) should be shipped flat in rigid mailers with stiff cardboard backing. Do not fold or bend booklets. PSA provides specific instructions for booklet submissions — follow them exactly. Read our complete shipping guide for detailed packing instructions.
Is Grading Thick Cards Worth It?
• Card value at expected grade > $250
• Patch is premium (logo, nameplate, 3+ colors)
• Card stock and patch are in excellent condition
• You have 70%+ confidence in PSA 9+ or BGS 9.5+
Do NOT grade when:
• Card value at expected grade < $150
• Patch is single-color common
• Patch is faded, frayed, or stained
• Card has visible corner/edge wear
Thick Card ROI Example:
| Card | Raw Value | PSA 10 Value | Grading Cost | Net Profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mahomes NFL Shield 1/1 | $5,000 | $15,000 | $105 | +$9,895 |
| Common jersey patch | $15 | $60 | $105 | −$45 |
| Jumbo logo patch /25 | $300 | $900 | $105 | +$595 |
Bottom Line: Thick card grading is worth it for premium patches and high-value cards. The extra fees ($10-25) are negligible on cards worth $500+, but they make low-value thick cards unprofitable. Pre-screen with AI, measure thickness accurately, use proper supplies, and only submit cards with strong profit potential. Prepare your cards properly before submission.
Frequently Asked Questions
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Sources & Further Reading
With submission floors rising, pre-screening is no longer optional. Use our AI Pre-Grade Calculator to score a card's PSA 10 odds before you pay, and the Submission Planner to pick the right tier.