The Short Answer
- The 2026 Topps Flagship #309 base rookie is $1.06–$1.99 raw, with PSA 9s around $22.50 and PSA 10s around $62.11.
- Love averaged 4.1 yards per carry for 223 yards and 62 receiving yards before an ankle injury sent him to injured reserve.
- The Holo parallel sells at $5.25 raw and $54.35 in PSA 10 — a 10x gem multiple.
- The Independence Day /76 parallel is $119.99 raw, the scarcest Flagship card in this guide.
- The rookie auto lists at $250, the highest-value Love card with real liquidity.
- Injury risk is the whole thesis: buy the dip or wait for his return, not both.
Why Jeremiyah Love Is a Buy-the-Dip Candidate
Jeremiyah Love was the most complete running back in the 2026 class: a 6-foot, 210-pound back with receiver hands and home-run speed. Through the first month he averaged 4.1 yards per carry for 223 yards and added 62 receiving yards, and the Cardinals were building their offense around him. Then an ankle injury sent him to injured reserve.
That is why his cards are cheap. The base rookie is $1.06–$1.99, the Holo is $5.25, and the Gold /2026 is $20–$25. Compare that with Mendoza, whose PSA 10 is $350 after one starting-job announcement. Love has the better college résumé and the worse current news cycle.
Injury dips are the most reliable buying pattern in rookie cards. A player does not lose talent in an MRI tube, but the market reprices him as if he might. If Love returns healthy in December, the base card will not stay at $1.50.
The counter-argument is real: running backs have short careers, ankle injuries recur, and the Cardinals may limit his workload on return. Size the position as a bet on health, not a sure thing.
Jeremiyah Love Card Prices at a Glance
Love's ladder is steeper than Tate's because the /76 and the auto carry real scarcity. The base and Holo are the injury-dip plays; the numbered cards are the long-term holds.
| Card | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 | Tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 Topps Flagship #309 base | $1.06–$1.99 | ~$22.50 | ~$62.11 | Entry |
| #309 Holo | ~$5.25 | ~$18.34 | ~$54.35 | Parallel |
| #309 Gold /2026 | $19.99–$25 | — | — | Parallel |
| #309 Independence Day /76 | $119.99 | — | — | Scarce |
| #309 Rookie Auto | — | — | ~$250 | Auto |
Prices are from active listings and recent sales. Injury news moves this market faster than any other in the class.
No. 1 — 2026 Topps Flagship #309 Base Rookie

The base rookie is the injury-dip card. At $1.06–$1.99 raw, you are paying almost nothing for a first-round running back who was averaging 4.1 yards per carry before the ankle injury. A PSA 9 is about $22.50 and a PSA 10 about $62.11.
The gem multiple here is healthy — roughly 40x from raw to PSA 10 — which means the market still believes in the player even while it discounts the injury. That is the signature of a buy-the-dip card rather than a broken one.
Buy ten raw copies. If Love returns in December and has a 100-yard game, the base card doubles before the PSA 10s even sell.
Check recent eBay sold prices for the 2026 Topps Flagship #309 →
No. 2 — 2026 Topps Flagship Holo #309
The Holo parallel is the cheapest way to own a Love card with a foil finish. It sells for about $5.25 raw, with PSA 9s around $18.34 and PSA 10s around $54.35.
That is a roughly 10x gem multiple on a $5 card, which is unusually attractive for a modern parallel. The catch is that grading a $5 card costs five times the card's value, so the only sane route is bulk submission.
Buy it for the look. The Holo finish makes a cheap card feel premium, and it displays well next to the base rookie.
Check recent eBay sold prices for the Holo #309 →
No. 3 — 2026 Topps Flagship Gold #309 /2026
The Gold border parallel is numbered to 2026 and sells for $19.99–$25. For a first-round running back, that is cheap — Golds of comparable players in the 2025 class trade higher.
Numbered parallels are the best risk-adjusted way to own an injured rookie. The print run is fixed, the price is low, and the card does not depend on a weekly stat line to hold value.
If you want one Love card that is not a $2 base card, this is the one. It is scarce enough to matter and cheap enough to hold through a rehab.
Check recent eBay sold prices for the Gold /2026 →
No. 4 — 2026 Topps Flagship 1991 35th #91TR-9
The 1991 35th Anniversary insert is the cheapest Love card with a distinct design. It sells for roughly $1, in line with the rest of the 20-card rookie insert set.
These inserts are treated as filler by most collectors, which is exactly why they are fun. They cost nothing, they look different from the base set, and they complete a page in a binder without costing a fortune.
There is no investment case. There is a collection case: a full 1991 insert set of the 2026 class is a nice snapshot of the rookie year for about $25.
Check recent eBay sold prices for the 1991 35th insert →
- Sports Card Auto and Mem and Graded cards pack — $10.00 on eBay →
- sports cards graded 10 — $150.00 on eBay →
- $100 Sports Mystery Graded Card | NFL, NBA, or MLB — $100.00 on eBay →
- sports card singles graded — $35.00 on eBay →
Ad · Listings shown are from eBay. We may earn a commission when you buy through these eBay links. Prices and availability are set by eBay sellers and change often.
No. 5 — 2026 Topps Flagship Independence Day #309 /76
The Independence Day parallel is numbered to 76 and was listed at $119.99 on 14 November. It is the scarcest Love card in this guide and the best-looking of the Flagship parallels.
Seventy-six copies is a real print run, and the July 4 design is one of the more collectible retail chases in the 2026 set. For a running back with an injury question, it is a bet on talent over news.
This is the card to buy if you believe Love is the long-term answer in Arizona. It is expensive relative to his base card but cheap relative to what a healthy 1,200-yard season would do to the price.
Check recent eBay sold prices for the Independence Day /76 →
No. 6 — Bonus: 2026 Topps Flagship Rookie Auto #309
The bonus card is the autograph. A 2026 Topps Flagship Jeremiyah Love Rookie Auto #309 was listed at $250, which makes it the most valuable Love card with real liquidity.
Autographs are where running back cards concentrate value, because the position produces fewer collectible cards than quarterback and receiver. A signed rookie of a first-round back is a cleaner long-term hold than a stack of base cards.
Buy it if you want one Love card that will still matter in five years. The base cards are a trade; the auto is a collection piece.
Check recent eBay sold prices for the Rookie Auto #309 →
How to Buy Love During the Injury Dip
The pattern is simple: buy base and Holo now, buy the numbered cards if you believe, and wait for the return before buying the auto. Injury news creates the discount; the return creates the exit.
A $100 budget buys about fifty base rookies or one Independence Day /76. The base cards have more upside per dollar; the /76 has more scarcity. Pick based on whether you want a trade or a collection piece.
The risk to manage is reinjury. Ankle injuries are the most common cause of a lost second season for running backs, and the Cardinals have no incentive to rush him back in a lost year.
- Buy the dip, not the news: base cards are $1.06–$1.99 while he is on IR.
- Holo is the cheap parallel: $5.25 raw with a 10x gem multiple.
- Gold /2026 is the balanced hold: fixed print run, $20–$25.
- Independence Day /76 is the scarcity bet: $119.99 for 76 copies.
- Do not grade cheap cards alone: the fee exceeds the card value.
- Watch the return timeline: a December return is the catalyst.
Run a free AI pre-grade on your card →
Watch & Learn: Love's College Tape
The best available look at Love is his college film. Watch the contact balance and the receiving work, then judge whether $1.50 is too cheap for a first-round back.
The Full NFL Card Series
The hub has the full ranking, the five-tier price ladder and the entry card for every player in the class.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Jeremiyah Love's best rookie card?
The 2026 Topps Flagship #309 is his base NFL rookie. The Independence Day /76 is the scarcest Flagship parallel and the Rookie Auto is the most valuable.
How much is a Jeremiyah Love rookie card worth in 2026?
Base #309: $1.06–$1.99 raw, about $22.50 in PSA 9 and $62.11 in PSA 10. Gold /2026: $19.99–$25. Independence Day /76: $119.99. Rookie Auto: about $250.
Should I buy Jeremiyah Love cards while he is injured?
Injury dips are the most reliable buying pattern in rookie cards, but running backs carry reinjury risk. Buy base cards as a low-cost bet, not a core holding.
Is Jeremiyah Love's card a good investment?
It is a volatile bet on health. The base card has more upside per dollar; the numbered parallels are better holds.
Why is Love's PSA 10 multiple so high?
Because the base card is only $1.06–$1.99 while the PSA 10 is about $62 — roughly 40x. That reflects market belief in the player despite the injury.
Sources & Further Reading
- SportCardsPro — 2026 Topps Flagship values
- NFL — midseason All-Rookie Team
- Ourlads — All-Rookie Team mid-season
- eBay sold listings — 2026 Topps Jeremiyah Love
Create a free account and get 1,5 free credits. No credit card required.
Get Your Free Credits →


