Football Player Guide

Ty Simpson Rookie Cards: 5 to Buy in 2026 — Plus the $4,400 Golden Mirror

Simpson is the heir to Matthew Stafford in Los Angeles and his base card is still $1.29–$2.00. Here are five cards to buy, plus the Golden Mirror that lists at $950 raw and $4,437 in a PSA 10.

Marcus Chen Published Nov 14, 2026 Updated Nov 14, 2026 6 min read
2026 Topps Flagship Ty Simpson rookie card and rare parallel on a dark table
Share This Article

The Short Answer

  • The 2026 Topps Flagship #302 base rookie is $1.29–$2.00 raw, with PSA 9s around $19 and PSA 10s around $68.
  • A “first PSA 10” copy was listed at $499.98 — a reminder that asks are not comps.
  • The True Photo Variation is $124.29 raw, $241.29 in PSA 9 and $705.34 in PSA 10.
  • The Golden Mirror SSP is $950 raw and $4,437.72 in PSA 10 — the ceiling card.
  • The rookie auto Gold lists at $1,699 and the Bowman Sapphire Gold /50 at $999.
  • Simpson sits behind Matthew Stafford, so his value is a bet on the succession plan, not on 2026 starts.

Why Ty Simpson Is a Bet on 2027

Ty Simpson was the second quarterback taken in the 2026 draft and he landed in the best possible situation: behind Matthew Stafford on a Rams team that knows how to develop quarterbacks. He will not start in 2026 unless Stafford is injured, and that is exactly why his cards are interesting.

The market prices backups at a discount and starting jobs at a premium. Simpson's base rookie is $1.29–$2.00, while his True Photo Variation is $124.29 and his Golden Mirror is $950 raw. The spread between the base card and the short prints is enormous because the short prints are scarce, not because the market expects him to start this season.

That structure creates a specific trade: buy the cheap base and numbered cards now, and let the succession plan do the work. If Stafford retires or moves on after 2026, Simpson becomes a starting quarterback and the base card reprices. If Stafford plays three more years, the base card drifts.

The risk is timing. A backup quarterback can sit for years, and card demand decays when there is no weekly stat line.

Ty Simpson: the 2026 card ladderTy Simpson: the 2026 card ladderLive eBay and market values, 14 November 2026Base raw$1.29–$2.00PSA 10 base~$68True Photo raw$124.29True Photo PSA 10$705.34Golden Mirror raw$950Golden Mirror PSA 10$4,437.72Square-root scale. The Golden Mirror PSA 10 is 65 times the base PSA 10.

Ty Simpson Card Prices at a Glance

Simpson has the widest spread between base and short print in the 2026 class. The base card is a $2 lottery ticket; the Golden Mirror is a $950 bet on the same player.

Market values and active listings, 14 November 2026, USD.
CardRawPSA 9PSA 10Tier
2026 Topps Flagship #302 base$1.29–$2.00~$19~$68Entry
#302 True Photo Variation$124.29$241.29$705.34Scarce
#302 Golden Mirror SSP$950$1,518.84$4,437.72Grail
#302 Rookie Auto Gold——~$1,699Auto
2026 Bowman Sapphire Gold /50——~$999Scarce

A “first PSA 10” base card was listed at $499.98. That is an ask, not a comp — the market PSA 10 is around $68.

Try it on your own cards — free 1.5 free credits · instant AI grade + market value · no credit card required
Get Free Credits →

No. 1 — 2026 Topps Flagship #302 Base Rookie

The base rookie is the cheapest way to bet on the Rams' succession plan. At $1.29–$2.00 raw, with a PSA 9 around $19 and a PSA 10 around $68, it is priced like a backup quarterback — which, for now, he is.

The PSA 10 at $68 is the highest base-card gem in this guide, which tells you the market is already pricing some succession risk. That is a good sign: the floor is higher than for a defensive rookie, and the ceiling depends on Stafford.

Buy ten and hold them until there is news about the starting job.

The photo above shows the Crackle Foil parallel; the base card uses the same image on standard stock.

Grade noteDo not grade a $1.60 card on its own. The PSA 10 at $68 is attractive, but the fee is $25–$40 and the outcome is uncertain.
Raw
$1.29–$2.00
PSA 9
~$19
PSA 10
~$68

Check recent eBay sold prices for the 2026 Topps Flagship #302 →

No. 2 — 2026 Topps Flagship #302 in PSA 10

The PSA 10 base sells for about $68, though a hopeful seller listed a “first PSA 10” copy at $499.98 on 14 November. Do not pay the ask; the market number is $68.

This is a useful lesson in reading listings. A “first graded” label is marketing, not a comp. The card is the same card, and the population will grow every week.

Buy the slab at market if you want one, and ignore the outliers.

Grade noteBuy the grade, not the story. A $499.98 ask on a $68 card is a sell-side fantasy.
Raw
$1.29–$2.00 (raw)
PSA 9
~$19
PSA 10
~$68 (ask $499.98)

Check recent eBay sold prices for a PSA 10 #302 →

No. 3 — 2026 Topps Flagship True Photo Variation #302

The True Photo Variation is a short print with a different image, and it sells for $124.29 raw, $241.29 in PSA 9 and $705.34 in PSA 10. It is the most accessible Simpson short print.

Photo variations are the cards that separate player collectors from set builders. They are scarce, they look different, and they hold value better than base cards because the supply is fixed by the short-print ratio.

Buy it if you want one Simpson card that is not a $2 base card.

Grade noteThe PSA 10 at $705 is roughly 5.7 times the raw price, which justifies grading a clean copy.
Raw
$124.29
PSA 9
$241.29
PSA 10
$705.34

Check recent eBay sold prices for the True Photo Variation →

No. 4 — 2026 Topps Flagship Rookie Auto Gold #302

A 2026 Topps Flagship Ty Simpson Rookie Auto Gold was listed at $1,699. It is a signed, gold-parallel rookie of a quarterback who has not started a game — the purest expression of succession-plan pricing.

Quarterback autographs carry the highest ceilings in football cards because the position drives demand. If Simpson becomes a starter in 2027, this card will look cheap. If he does not, it will look expensive.

Buy it only if you believe in the Rams' plan.

Grade noteAt this level, verify the auto, the parallel, and the seller. Buy graded or from a dealer with references.
Raw
—
PSA 9
—
PSA 10
~$1,699

Check recent eBay sold prices for the Rookie Auto Gold →

SponsoredRight Now on eBay

Ad · Listings shown are from eBay. We may earn a commission when you buy through these eBay links. Prices and availability are set by eBay sellers and change often.

No. 5 — 2026 Bowman Sapphire Gold /50

The Bowman Sapphire Chrome Gold parallel is numbered to 50 and was listed at $999. Sapphire is a premium chromium product with a small print run, and the Gold /50 is one of the scarcest Simpson cards in existence.

Bowman Sapphire cards are pre-draft, so this is not his NFL rookie. But scarcity is scarcity, and a /50 quarterback card from a premium product has a real collector base.

Buy it as a long-term hold, not a trade.

Grade noteSapphire surfaces show scratches. Only buy a copy with clean photos, and prefer graded examples at this price.
Raw
—
PSA 9
—
PSA 10
~$999

Check recent eBay sold prices for the Sapphire Gold /50 →

Instant AI Pre-Screen Have this card in hand? Check it right now Get an instant prediction for PSA 10 centering, corners, and surface with 1.5 free credits.
Check My Card Free →

No. 6 — Bonus: 2026 Topps Flagship Golden Mirror SSP #302

The bonus card is the ceiling. A Golden Mirror image variation of the #302 was listed at $950 raw, with PSA 9 copies at $1,518.84 and a PSA 10 at $4,437.72.

That is 65 times the price of his base PSA 10, for the same player. The difference is scarcity: Golden Mirrors are short prints, and a quarterback short print in a premium product attracts both player collectors and speculators.

Do not chase it unless you are a Simpson believer with a long horizon. At $950, you are paying for the possibility that he becomes a starter.

Grade noteAt this price, buy graded or through an auction house. Verify the variation and the cert before payment.
Raw
$950
PSA 9
$1,518.84
PSA 10
$4,437.72

Check recent eBay sold prices for the Golden Mirror SSP →

How to Buy a Backup Quarterback

Simpson is a timing trade, not a talent trade. The talent is real — he was a second-round pick with a good arm — but the value depends on when he gets a starting job.

The sensible plan: ten base cards, one True Photo Variation, and one numbered card. That is a complete position for under $200. Skip the Golden Mirror and the auto unless you have a strong view on Stafford's timeline.

The catalyst is news. A Stafford retirement, a trade, or an injury would reprice the entire Simpson market overnight. Until then, the cards drift.

Simpson buying checklist
  • Base at $1.60 is the trade: a second-round quarterback for a coffee.
  • PSA 10 is $68, not $499.98: ignore “first graded” asks.
  • True Photo Variation is the best mid-tier card: $124 raw, $705 in PSA 10.
  • Skip the Golden Mirror unless you believe: $950 raw prices the succession.
  • Watch Stafford news: the timeline is the whole thesis.
  • Do not grade base cards on their own: the fee is $25–$40.

Run a free AI pre-grade on your card →

Watch & Learn: Simpson's Preseason Tape

Simpson's preseason work is the best available evidence. Watch the arm and the decisions, then judge whether $1.60 is too cheap for a Rams succession plan.

The Full NFL Card Series

25 players, 150 cards, one ladderThis guide is part of a 25-player NFL card series — 20 rising stars and 5 GOATs, each with six cards and live prices. Open the NFL card hub →

The hub has the full ranking, the five-tier price ladder and the entry card for every player in the class.

SponsoredRight Now on eBaySee all on eBay →

Ad · Listings shown are from eBay. We may earn a commission when you buy through these eBay links. Prices and availability are set by eBay sellers and change often.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Ty Simpson's best rookie card?

The 2026 Topps Flagship #302 base is the entry card. The True Photo Variation is the best mid-tier card and the Golden Mirror is the grail.

How much is a Ty Simpson rookie card worth in 2026?

Base #302: $1.29–$2.00 raw, about $19 in PSA 9 and $68 in PSA 10. True Photo Variation: $124.29 raw, $705.34 in PSA 10. Golden Mirror: $950 raw, $4,437.72 in PSA 10.

Is Ty Simpson starting for the Rams in 2026?

No. He sits behind Matthew Stafford. His card value is a bet on the succession plan, not on 2026 starts.

Should I pay $499.98 for a “first PSA 10” Ty Simpson base card?

No. The market PSA 10 is about $68. “First graded” is marketing, not a comp.

What is the scarcest Ty Simpson card?

The Golden Mirror SSP and the Bowman Sapphire Gold /50 are the scarcest widely traded cards. Both are numbered short prints.

Sources & Further Reading

Marcus Chen
Marcus Chen Contributor

Marcus Chen has evaluated over 50,000 sports cards and TCG cards across PSA, BGS, SGC, and CGC standards. Before joining PreGradeCards, he worked as a submission specialist for a major grading company and trained collectors and dealers on condition assessment.

Ready to grade your own cards?

Create a free account and get 1.5 free credits. No credit card required.

Get Your Free Credits →
Or try the free tools first: AI Pre-Grade Calculator · Submission Planner

Related Coverage