PSA Buyback Scandal 2026: What the #PSAUp-Gate Controversy Means for Baseball Card Grading Trust
The #PSAUp-Gate scandal revealed that PSA's Direct Buyback Program created a structural conflict of interest: PSA grades cards, then buys them at its own valuation, and some cards reappear with higher grades. 11 cards bought as PSA 9s reappeared as PSA 10s.